Join our New York News e mail publication to get information, updates, and native insights delivered straight to your inbox!
A brand new state legislation banning the retail sale of pets has some longstanding NYC pet store house owners anxious that the legislation will harm their companies whereas additionally failing to guard animal welfare.
State information present there are at the moment 25 licensed pet sellers all through the 5 boroughs: six within the Bronx, 5 every in Brooklyn and Manhattan, eight in Queens and one on Staten Island.
The Pet Mill Pipeline Act, signed by Gov. Kathy Hochul in 2022, takes impact Dec. 15 and prohibits retail pet retailers from promoting canine, cats, and rabbits. Queens state Sen. Michael Gianaris and Manhattan Meeting Member Linda Rosenthal co-sponsored the laws. Metropolis laws to bolster the state legislation not too long ago handed the Metropolis Council by a margin of 40 votes to five.
Nonetheless, the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) celebrated the passage of the legislation in 2022 as a “big win.” It mentioned the ban will “end the flow of cruelly bred puppies into New York.”
In a press release reminding New Yorkers of the legislation, Legal professional Basic Letitia James mentioned that folks searching for their subsequent furry good friend ought to undertake from native rescue businesses or undergo a licensed breeder. “This pet sale ban will help put an end to the dangerous puppy mill to pet store pipeline that endangers pets and costs New Yorkers thousands of dollars in veterinary care.”
Shutting down store
In keeping with Santiago, Pet Boutique has been on eightieth Avenue between sixteenth and seventeenth avenues for the final 30 years and employs about 12 staff, who at the moment are involved for his or her livelihoods.
Throughout the 5 boroughs, some native pet retailer house owners who say they’ve acted responsibly for years imagine the legislation unfairly punishes them — and with out their companies, that are regulated by the town and state, they fear many New Yorkers will find yourself shopping for out of state, thereby reducing native tax income, or perpetuating the underground market.
They’re additionally involved about their very own backside line and the welfare of their workers.
For some, the harm is already finished. Zoo-Rama Pets on East Tremont Avenue within the Bronx, which opened in 1998, is slated to shut on Dec. 14, the day earlier than the ban takes impact.
Throughout a current go to, indicators on the window introduced the shop’s impending closure and promoted a pet sale with costs beginning at $795. Over the previous couple of weeks, Zoo-Rama has labored shortly to promote its stock forward of the legislation’s implementation and has discovered new houses for about three-quarters of its stock, mentioned a supervisor who requested to not be named within the story.
Though the shop carries pet meals and provides and gives grooming companies, the supervisor mentioned 90% of earnings come from the sale of animals, leaving an enormous hole to fill when the ban takes impact.
“We are closing only because of this law,” he mentioned. The Legal professional Basic’s workplace declined to touch upon the consequences of the pet sale ban on native companies.
The supervisor known as the ban “very insane and unjust” and mentioned Zoo-Rama plans to file for Chapter 13 chapter safety whereas its six to eight staff file for unemployment. The shop can be celebration to a newly filed lawsuit towards Hochul within the State Supreme Court docket of Suffolk County, aiming to cease the legislation.
The supervisor mentioned his retailer is doing the whole lot proper, even exceeding state and metropolis requirements. All puppies are checked by three completely different veterinarians (together with not less than one that’s USDA-certified) and include NYC pet licenses and information of vaccinations and a fecal examination, which the supervisor mentioned shouldn’t be required. New house owners additionally obtain a thick packet of paperwork proving every animal’s breeder and well being historical past.
“We did the right thing by providing quality puppies with all the paperwork,” the supervisor mentioned. “I’m really sad about this.”
A pet on the market at Citypets in ChelseaPhoto by Jada Camille
In the meantime, Metropolis Pets, which has a location in Chelsea, Manhattan, is promoting off all of its puppies earlier than Dec. 15 — and it’s future stays relatively questionable with the brand new legislation in place.
One long-time retailer worker, who recognized himself as Norman, mentioned the store will possible shut and relocate out-of-state. For the corporate, it now not is smart to stay open since enterprise is essentially based mostly on the sale of puppies.
“We’ve been here 40 years. People know who we are,” Norman mentioned, including that patrons who come to Metropolis Pets “don’t want rescue dogs.”
“I enjoyed working here,” Norman added.
‘We’re making an attempt to battle’
A buyer with the brand new pet he took dwelling throughout our go to to the Bronx Zoo-Rama store on Dec. 4. The poodle is the second canine he purchased from Zoo-Rama.Photograph by Emily Swanson
Nasser Ahmed, proprietor of Self-importance Pups in Bayside, Queens, mentioned his retailer has all the time supplied quite a lot of different companies comparable to grooming, daycare and equipment and mentioned the shop will likely be pivoting to focus totally on such companies as soon as the legislation comes into impact.
Nonetheless, he anticipates a difficult interval as soon as the legislation comes into impact on Sunday and he’s bracing for an enormous hit to the shop’s income. Ahmed mentioned he can be letting go of 4 workers members and would cut back the variety of workers on the retailer from 5 to at least one till he may gauge the affect that the legislation has had on his enterprise.
“A lot of stores are closing,” Ahmed mentioned. “I’m going to have to let go of basically my entire staff and come down to just me running the store until I see how things go along, but I’m expecting a huge hit as far as revenue goes. So it’s going to be very challenging to stay open. We’ve been here for 26 years, so we’re trying to fight to stay open to keep this place going. We know we’re going to be here for 2025, but we’re really in question about 2026 and going further, depending on how the next year looks.”
Ahmed mentioned he has been informing his workers to search for alternatives since Hochul signed the laws into legislation in December 2022.
He believes that the legislation is not going to be efficient at clamping down on pet farms, stating that breeders will now be capable to elevate their costs when promoting to New Yorkers instantly. He additionally believes New Yorkers searching for a brand new pet will journey to neighboring states comparable to Connecticut or New Jersey, the place pet shops will nonetheless be free to promote canine, cats and rabbits.
He added that the legislation is a “bad way” to handle pet farming and that it could be way more efficient if the state legislature applied a follow of figuring out which pet shops are utilizing “bad breeders.”
Benjamin Santiago, the final supervisor of Pet Boutique in Bensonhurst, spoke to us Monday whereas surrounded by some 20 pups he hopes will likely be bought earlier than Sunday’s deadline.
“We’ll figure something out. These guys are not going to go back anywhere. They’re going to end up being in someone’s home. I’ll even grab a couple myself,” he mentioned.
In keeping with Santiago, Pet Boutique has been on eightieth Avenue between sixteenth and seventeenth avenues for the final 30 years and employs about 12 staff, who at the moment are involved for his or her livelihoods.
He confused that their pets come from respected breeders inspected by the FDA.
“I understand that they’re trying to cut off the puppy mills, but was does our pet store have to do with that,” mentioned Santiago. “The job of eliminating most of those puppy mills is for the FDA, they are supposed to handle that, not us. But it’s the mom-and-pop stores who are paying for it.”
Two of the canine ready on new houses at Zoo-Rama on Dec. 4, 2024.Photograph by Emily Swanson
Stopping ‘backyard breeders’
Alternatively, LIC Feral Feeders, a non-profit devoted to offering important care to homeless and feral cats in Lengthy Island Metropolis, has welcomed the brand new legislation.
Jannatul Ahmed, director of operations on the nonprofit, mentioned she hopes the legislation will assist get rid of “backyard breeders” and individuals who exploit animals for his or her complete life for monetary profit.
“If stores are no longer able to sell animals, the vision is really that they will remain pet stores and sell pet-related products,” Ahmed mentioned. “But they will offer animals for adoption and help with moving the needle a little bit toward reducing the overpopulation of cats, dogs, guinea pigs, rabbits, you name it.”
Jenny Tsai, founding father of Tiny Cuties, an Astoria-based service that sells puppies and kittens after ethically breeding them with “breeding parents”, mentioned the legislation will drive various New York Metropolis-based pet shops to shutter completely or relocate to New Jersey.
Tsai mentioned Tiny Cuties, which doesn’t function a storefront, is not going to be impacted by the incoming legislation and mentioned it the laws will assist to get rid of pet farming and clamp down on individuals who “don’t treat animals well.”
